The debate over cruise gratuities has gone too far. Let’s put an end to it.
We just got off a phenomenal 22-night sailing aboard the Ruby Princess. The service? Five-star. Our stateroom host? A rockstar. Our dining team? Absolute legends. It was the kind of cruise that reminded us why we love to travel—where people go above and beyond to make every moment special.
But then came the final night—and with it, an uncomfortable realization.
We found out that the crew who served us so incredibly well wouldn’t directly receive much—if any—of the $800 we prepaid in Cruise Gratuities.
Cue the panic.
We didn’t have enough cash on hand to properly thank the individuals who made our cruise unforgettable. We felt embarrassed. Had we known earlier, we would’ve personally handed our stateroom host $200+ (it was a 22-night cruise, after all) and slipped a well-deserved envelope to every member of our dining team.
We had the intention—but not the information.
Not All Gratuities Are Created Equal
Cruise lines love to throw around words like crew appreciation, pooled funds, and incentive programs. But what does any of that actually mean for the people folding your towels or remembering your drink order every night?
Let’s break it down:
🛳️ Princess Cruises – Optional, Pooled
Prepaid gratuities are pooled (minus credit card fees) and distributed as bonuses to crewmembers fleetwide. That includes your servers, your cabin steward—but also behind-the-scenes folks you may never see. It’s a group approach, but it can leave direct-service crew with less than you’d expect.
🛳️ Royal Caribbean – Optional
Gratuities go to dining, bar, housekeeping, and other hotel services teams. It’s more direct than Princess, but still shared broadly across the service departments.
🛳️ Carnival – Mandatory, but Removable
Here’s a more straightforward system. Carnival distributes 100% of the gratuities to the crew you interact with. That means your stateroom attendant and dining staff are getting their share.
🛳️ Norwegian Cruise Line (NCL) – Mandatory
NCL sticks with a “team-based” pay model. Gratuities support both guest-facing and behind-the-scenes crew. There’s no opting out, and it supports a wide range of staff—not just those directly serving you.
🛳️ Disney Cruise Line – Optional
If you prepay gratuities, they’re clearly earmarked: your dining servers and stateroom host. No guesswork, just direct appreciation.
🛳️ Virgin Voyages – None
No gratuities. It’s baked into the price. Refreshing, right?
So… Are Cruise Gratuities Out of Control?
Here’s the thing: gratuities shouldn’t be that different than tipping at your favorite resort, hotel, or restaurant. If someone gives you exceptional service, you tip them—personally.
But the cruise industry muddies the waters. Some lines pool tips into company-run bonus programs. Others give you the option to remove them entirely. Some don’t charge gratuities at all and just build them into the fare.
In the U.S., we’re used to tipping 15–20% because the system relies on it. Workers make lower base wages and depend on those tips. That expectation doesn’t always exist in other countries, and that’s fine. But on a cruise, especially one sailing out of North America, guests are often caught between gratuity culture and company policy—and the results can feel pretty murky.
Here’s Our Take: Tip Like You Mean It
If the service is exceptional, don’t rely on the default charge. Take a few envelopes and some cash. Thank your stateroom host, your waitstaff, your bartender. If it matters to you that your gratitude goes directly to the person who earned it, then make it personal.
And if you’re unsure how your cruise line handles gratuities? Ask at the start of your trip. Not the end.
At THK Travel, we believe appreciation should be intentional. Gratuities shouldn’t be a source of guilt or confusion—they should be a way to say, “Hey, you made my trip better. Thank you.”
So, are cruise line gratuities going too far? Maybe. But with the right knowledge, you can make sure your thanks actually land where they’re meant to.
🎒 Travel tip from THK: Bring a stash of small bills and a few thank-you cards in your suitcase. You’ll never regret tipping someone who made your trip amazing.
Let us know your experiences with cruise gratuities! Have you had a tipping surprise—or a moment that made you rethink how you give thanks at sea?
Back to the blog
